Should ‘say what you pay’ include pension contributions?
Image: Mclittle/Adobe Stock
Pardon the Interruption
This article is just an example of the content available to mallowstreet members.
On average over 150 pieces of new content are published from across the industry per month on mallowstreet. Members get access to the latest developments, industry views and a range of in-depth research.
All the content on mallowstreet is accredited for CPD by the PMI and is available to trustees for free.
The government plans to make publishing salaries in job ads a legal requirement, Number 10 said earlier this month – but will this include employer pension contributions?
A government consultation proposing the new ‘say what you pay’ law had the backing of 94% of respondents, the government said, including 93% of businesses. The government cites estimates that fewer than half (41%) of employers always publish salary ranges and just 18% always publish specific salaries.
The planned requirement aims to help expose unjustified differences in pay, give workers greater confidence to challenge discrimination and prevent disagreements over pay escalating into disputes, and legislation will be brought forward "as soon as possible", according to Downing Street.
"Whether you’re a young person starting out or a parent trying to support your family, you should know what a job pays before spending your time and effort applying for it. That’s why we will make it a legal requirement for all employers to say what you pay," PM Andy Burnham said on 5 November.
However, few details are yet available on how 'pay' will be defined, and specifically, whether it will include pensions. The consultation sought views on including information such as other financial benefits, collective bargaining provisions and annual adjustments.
A government spokesperson said: "We’ve announced making basic pay information mandatory, as this is crucial information for applicants. We are assessing whether conditions beyond basic pay would be proportionate for businesses. We will respond in full to the consultation in due course."
The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, which responded to the government's pay consultation, supports including pension contributions in job ads, saying this could improve employee awareness as well as benchmark employers in the market.
“The CIPD believes it is good practice for employers to include pension contributions in job adverts because they are deferred pay and a key part of reward. However, only 41% of employers currently do so," said Charles Cotton, senior policy and practice adviser at the CIPD.
Research found 16% of workers do not know what type of pension scheme they are enrolled in, while 33% of those who know they have a workplace pension are unsure how much their employer contributes, he pointed out.
"Greater transparency around employer contribution rates could help employees make more informed decisions and encourage employers to review how their pension offering compares with others in the market. The government should consider this measure as a way of improving transparency, supporting better retirement outcomes, and potentially helping to narrow pension gaps,” he added.
Employers appear cautiously supportive of greater transparency in job ads.
"Providing pay information in job adverts can help candidates make informed decisions and is already established good practice for many businesses," said Rain Newton-Smith, chief executive of the Confederation of British Industry.
"Getting the details right will be key to ensuring that greater transparency does not inadvertently discourage hiring by restricting how firms structure pay," she added.
As the government is now considering the responses to its consultation, and ahead of the Pensions Commission potentially recommending contribution increases, Pensions UK is rebranding its Pensions Quality Mark as Better Pensions Employer.
The relaunched accreditation first introduced in 2009 has four levels:
As the government is now considering the responses to its consultation, and ahead of the Pensions Commission potentially recommending contribution increases, Pensions UK is rebranding its Pensions Quality Mark as Better Pensions Employer.
The relaunched accreditation first introduced in 2009 has four levels:
- Bronze: 10% total contribution, with at least 5% from the employer
- Silver: 12% total contribution, with at least 6% from the employer
- Gold: 15% total contribution, with at least 10% from the employer
- Platinum: more than 15% total contribution, or more than 15% with an automatic escalation feature, with at least 10% from the employer.
Pensions UK's CEO Julian Mund said: “Better Pensions Employer recognises organisations that are already stepping up and making a meaningful investment in their employees’ futures. They are showing what better can look like, and we want to recognise that leadership and encourage more employers to follow their example.”
Should the industry lobby harder on making employer pension contributions transparent in job ads?