Milburn recommends delaying AE reforms for youth employment

Image: dsheremeta/Adobe Stock

Pardon the Interruption

This article is just an example of the content available to mallowstreet members.

On average over 150 pieces of new content are published from across the industry per month on mallowstreet. Members get access to the latest developments, industry views and a range of in-depth research.

All the content on mallowstreet is accredited for CPD by the PMI and is available to trustees for free.

In a potential setback to efforts to improve retirement adequacy, the Milburn report on young people not in education, employment or training recommends pushing back age and earnings threshold changes for auto-enrolment until at least 2031, to avoid hurting already fragile youth employment. 

Tuesday's long-awaited report by former Labour MP Alan Milburn – who has just been made chair of a new Youth Opportunities Unit – contains a raft of recommendations on how to tackle the UK's youth employment crisis. One of them is not to lower the pensions enrolment age to 18 or removing the lower earnings threshold of £6,240 for under-25s for another five years at least.  

These changes to enrolment eligibility, first recommended in 2017, have been on the cards since 2023, when legislation was passed giving ministers the power to implement them. 

"These reforms have merit in their own terms, but implementing them while youth employment is under pressure would add another cost at precisely the point when we need employers to create more first jobs," Milburn's report argues. 

It notes that there is currently uncertainty around auto-enrolment reforms because the powers exist but have not been used. 

"The uncertainty matters because businesses plan ahead on the assumption that these costs could arrive," he says in the report. "That is particularly important for SMEs, where relatively small increases in employment costs can have an outsized effect on whether another young person is recruited." 

Jobs and pensions should go hand in hand, says SPP


The recommendation not to add to employer costs by improving pensions comes as a blow to efforts to improve retirement adequacy, for which early saving and higher contributions are seen as key by industry experts, due to the power of compounding. 

It also runs directly counter to industry expectations that the Pensions Commission could recommend increasing the UK's current minimum employer contributions of 3%. 

The Society of Pension Professionals said it recognised concerns about pressure on employers and protecting jobs for young people but argues that jobs and pension saving should not be mutually exclusive.  

"We should be seeking to support young people into their first jobs while also helping them build financial security for their later lives. These objectives should go hand in hand, rather than being considered as competing priorities," said SPP president Calum Cooper.  

He called the debate about employer costs "legitimate" but added: "Postponing automatic enrolment improvements until 2031 risks leaving another generation of young people behind in building their financial security for retirement.”  

TISA wants to see government make use of 2023 powers in this parliament


The Investment and Saving Alliance's head of policy for products and long-term savings, Renny Biggins, was even clearer when he said the 2023 legislation to implement auto-enrolment changes around minimum age and removing the lower earnings threshold should be used now. 

"I think that government could bring that in within the current parliamentary term. It doesn't, as I say, require a legislative timetable to do that. Do that by 2030," he said speaking at the TISA Annual Conference on Tuesday.  

Biggins suggested further delays to increasing contribution levels from the current 8% should not be tolerated either: "What we would ask... is for the current government to show a commitment to that move to 12% by legislating now within the current parliamentary term for a future schedule of change. And say we start that in 2031 and we ratchet up contribution rates by half a percent a year." 

The first four years of increases would add to the employer contribution until 5% is reached, he proposed. In the UK, unusually in an international context, the employer can contribute a lower percentage than the employee, who puts in at least 5% including tax relief. Biggins suggested that for a further two years, contributions would then go up by 0.5% a year, so that a matching structure of 6% employer and 6% employee contribution is reached in 2037. 

"And if you think 2037, within 25 years after auto-enrolment started, it's taken that long to get to at this point. So I don't think that's an unreasonable request for us to make as an industry," he said.

More from mallowstreet