‘Are you an agent?’ Agentic AI set to rewrite member interactions

Image: Joi_studio/Adobe Stock

Pardon the Interruption

This article is just an example of the content available to mallowstreet members.

On average over 150 pieces of new content are published from across the industry per month on mallowstreet. Members get access to the latest developments, industry views and a range of in-depth research.

All the content on mallowstreet is accredited for CPD by the PMI and is available to trustees for free.

Artificial intelligence agents could have a huge impact on saver activity, and their use raises questions around accountability, a panel of pensions and investment experts has said, with one calling on the Pensions Commission to look at AI more closely.

The Financial Conduct Authority's recent Mills Review found that of over 5,000 financial services consumers, a fifth – around 11m UK adults – are open to using AI that can act autonomously within pre-set goals, and 13% of all consumers would be willing to give AI real-time access to banking and financial data. 

The rise of agentic AI, and some consumers' willingness to deploy it for their personal finances, is set to alter the relationship between pension funds and their members. 

Understand, check, recognise liability  


At the annual conference of the Investing and Saving Alliance held on Tuesday, this was put into stark relief when the head of pensions and investment policy at Scottish Widows, Peter Glancy, recounted a recent meeting in Lloyds Banking Group where a customer call was discussed. The call had gone on for five minutes when the call handler asked, "Are you an agent?", to which the response was: "Yes, I am." At this point, the customer picked up the phone and said they had programmed the agent to negotiate their renewal fee on an insurance product. 

For Glancy, the key issue in this was about liability. "If customers are deploying agents on their behalf, they need to take responsibility for what that agent does," he said.

However, the same applies to the sell-side, he acknowledged: "Similarly, we in the industry will want to use agents, maybe to be able to do things that we're not able to do today, or to do things at a lower cost. If we need to employ an agent, we need to be on the hook for it," argued Glancy.  

It will also be important that people still understand what is being done when they use AI, thinks director of policy and research at Cushon, Steve Watson. "I would call it informed inertia. So I'm giving it away to somebody else to deal with, but I know, I understand," he said.  

The Financial Conduct Authority takes a similar view when it comes to consumers and AI. Speaking at the same event, Kate Blatchford-Hick, head of consumer investments policy at the FCA, cited the Mills Review, saying agentic finance has potential but rests on trusted data, digital identity, secure execution and clear accountability.  

"We're also staying really close to the industry-led work in this area," she added.

The FCA is an observer on TISA's Agentic Customer Agents Working Group, which is considering how AI agents can safely interact with regulated financial services firms.   

"That kind of engagement and really getting the feedback live in real time, it's going to be so important as we work through the practical questions of how technology is going to work in the future," said Blatchford-Hick. "As AI agents develop, firms are going to need to think carefully about whether consumers understand when the agent is acting on their behalf, how authority is given, who is accountable, and how consumers can obtain and address to address when something goes wrong."

Call for Pensions Commission to link up with Mills Review team 


Agentic or not, AI is already changing what savers do. The Mills Review found consumers are most likely to turn to AI for finance where decisions feel complex or high-stakes, including pensions.

This is set to increase. Research conducted for Standard Life in the summer suggests while half of all UK adults who have used AI for pension information say it has influenced decisions about their retirement savings, that figure rises to 58% among Gen Z respondents. Among Gen Z, nearly a third (29%) used AI for pension information in the past year, compared with 16% of UK adults overall.

As AI is expected to become a feature of how people interact with pensions, some have therefore suggested this should be given greater prominence in setting the path of pensions over the next few decades through the Pensions Commission.

TISA's head of policy for products and long-term savings, Renny Biggins, suggested that although it is hard to build the impact of AI into policy recommendations for the next 50 years, policymakers should nevertheless attempt to do. 

"I think it'd be just be so useful for the people who wrote the Mills Review and the Pensions Commission to get together, because I think AI was fairly lightly covered in the Commission's work," he said. "But it is going to be something that's going to be very fundamental to the pensions framework over the next 50 years, so I'd like to see those two groups come together."

Regulators are aware of the big change that is underway. 
   
   
   
   

Do you expect AI to change savers' behaviour?

More from mallowstreet